Some Thoughts on Aereo

So today the Supreme Court ruled Aereo, the Internet TV streaming service, to be in violation of copyright law. And, at least to me, this was not unexpected.

I think one of the reasons that geeks glommed onto this service so much, besides a general dislike of copyright laws and a desire to stick it to big businesses and entrenched interests, is that we like clever things. And Aereo, with it’s “rent a single antenna” system, was one of the cleverest hacks I’ve seen in awhile to try to get around a legal roadblock.

But the minute I read what they were doing, I was thinking, “Yeah, this is really clever, but, man, they’re in for a world of legal trouble and it probably won’t end well for them.”

In essence, they were taking free over-the-air broadcasts and, through technological sleight-of-hand, were reselling it back to consumers through a subscription-based service with added enhancements. They created something that looked and acted very much like Hulu or cable TV with a DVR, but didn’t pay a cent to the over-the-air networks - something that cable companies and other re-broadcasters do have to.

They argued that this was legal because they assigned you a single antenna that was no different than having an antenna in your house. The Supreme Court disagreed. In this case, they applied “Duck Logic” to it - essentially, “if it looks like a duck and quacks like a duck, it should be treated like a duck, regardless of how it works on the inside.” How it works is not relevant when the end result is no different to consumers.

Consumers are licensed to receive free over-the-air broadcasts. But those broadcasts are intended for consumers, not for re-transmission by middlemen. Established and settled law has held that that different licenses cover re-transmission, and that the networks are entirely within their rights to demand payment for re-transmisson.

And while I appreciate Aereo’s technical cleverness, I have a hard time disagreeing with the Supreme Court’s conclusions.

What is surprising is the lengths to which the Supreme Court went to narrow this ruling, to such a degree that they devoted several pages specifically to pointing out other potential cases and how they are different and non-infriging. They’re sending a very strong signal to lower courts not to intepret this ruling in a wide way, as it pertains to a very specific circumstance.

This comment on Hacker News does a really good job of breaking down the ruling.

The thing is, everyone (including Aereo) is bemoaning this ruling, but I think there’s a great opportunity here. This doesn’t have to be the end of Aereo. Just license the content legally and brand yourself as “The Internet TV Source.” Become the better, awesome alternative to cable TV (because, let me tell you, my cable company is down there with the IRS in things that I like to deal with).

What annoys me, though, is that this ruling overshadowed a much more important ruling. In a 9-0 smackdown of a decision, the court ruled that police could not search a cell phone without a warrant. Why this was even up for debate is a mystery for me, but there you go. That ruling is very wide and far-reaching, and the effects of it is still being figured out, but that one ruling could very well shape a lof of cases very soon.

About the Author

Hi, I'm Rob! I'm a blogger and software developer. I wrote petfeedd, dystill, and various other projects and libraries. I'm into electronics, general hackery, and model trains and airplanes. I am based in Huntsville, Alabama, USA.

About Me · Contact Me · Don't Hire Isaiah Armstrong

Did this article help you out?

I don't earn any money from this site.

I run no ads, sell no products and participate in no affiliate programs. I do not accept gifts in exchange for articles, guest articles or link exchanges. I don't track you or sell your data. The only third-party Javascript on this website is Google Analytics.

In general I run this site very much like a 1990s homepage or early 2000s personal blog, meaning that I do this solely because it's fun! I enjoy writing and sharing what I learn.

If you found this article helpful and want to show your appreciation, a tip or donation would be very welcome. Feel free to choose from the options below.

Comments (0)

Interested in why you can't leave comments on my blog? Read the article about why comments are uniquely terrible and need to die. If you are still interested in commenting on this article, feel free to reach out to me directly and/or share it on social media.

Contact Me
Share It

Interested in reading more?


An Open Letter to Chief Justice Roy Moore

Those of my longtime readers will know that I very rarely if ever mention anything on this blog other than my ramblings on tech. But today is a very different day and I feel compelled to write about this. So I’ll ask for a mulligan. And, as always, my views here do not represent anything or anyone other than me.
Read More

You Need To Pay Better

So the good news is that things are stating to get better. The pandemic is starting to abate now that vaccines are widely available in the United States. Hopefully they will continue to be effective against the new strains that are emerging, and all evidence suggests that they are. Hopefully things will continue to improve around the world as well. Also equally good news is, with the pandemic abating, we can start to return to a more normal state. But many of us are emerging into a new world, one where it is basically impossible to buy a house because demand for houses is outpacing supply and where the costs of many things are going up due to scarcity. One of the interesting things I have noticed is that some businesses, and this seems to be predominantly fast food and restaurants, are having a hard time hiring people. Some have even shut down because they can’t find employees. What is happening here?
Read More

Some Work From Home Tips For Your COVID-19 Isolation

I’ve been working from home occasionally for probably close to ten years now, and full-time for the last few months. Thanks to the COVID-19 pandemic, many more people are now getting to enjoy (I guess?) the privilege of working from their homes during the crisis. If there is one thing that I hope comes out of this whole miserable period it is the understanding that there are a lot of people out there have jobs that really don’t need physical presence in an office building. And if they don’t need to be in an office, maybe they don’t need to live in an expensive city either. This could be the beginning of a whole new boom for small and mid-sized cities with affordable costs of living. Maybe you can afford a house after all! And maybe companies don’t need to lease out an expensive building in an expensive city, fill it to the brim with people in open floor plans or (even worse) hot-desking to do the work they need to do. It’s an even bigger win for disabled and non-neurotypical people who often struggle to work in the modern knowledge workforce despite their skills. For people with autism, ADHD, and other related conditions, modern open offices or cubicles are a difficult work environment whereas the home environment may offer much more safety and control. If this is your first time doing this, it may seem a bit odd, even naughty, to be working without commuting to an office building. With that in mind, I’ve put together a list of things I have observed over the years of working from home to help you get a feel for what this is like.
Read More